Plans for ‘spaceship-like’ lambing shed near Black Mountains

Herefordshire residents have objected to retrospective plans to build a ‘spaceship-like’ lambing shed which they say is an eyesore at the foot of the Black Mountains.

Applicant Christopher Brooks has built the open sided single bay shed on Proberts Farm, Hill Lane, Craswall, some 100 yards from the Black Hill which is within a site of special scientific interest.

Linden Alcock, the applicant’s agent, said the proposals would help Mr Brooks’ agricultural business achieve organic status.

He said: “The land at Craswall was seen to be an ideal opportunity to acquire uncontaminated pasture for flock establishment as part of this operation.

“Hence, the barn’s primary use is for lambing, secure storage of tools and equipment in this remote location and an insulated and heated section for shepherd and lambs.”

He also said that an extra bay was built at the open-ended side of the building due to a miscommunication between the contractor and the applicant’s agricultural advisers.

They had identified that the barn, as proposed, was not large enough on discovering that the land carries the right to graze more than 400 sheep.

But resident Timothy Heffer said the barn is an eyesore which is clearly visible at all times and is not suited to the proposed purpose as a lambing shed.

“No attempt has been made to reduce the visual impact of the building,” he said.

Objector Grace Watkins also said the building was intrusive and constructed higher than the original plan with different cladding and roof.

“The spaceship, glass clad abode would make a beautiful and very valuable piece of real estate,” she said.

“As it stands it is the single most glamorous sheep barn that has ever existed.”

Historic buildings consultant Nicholas Keeble, who also objected, said it would not be unreasonable to anticipate an application to change the use of the structure to a house.

He said:“Such a proposal would of course be entirely contrary to the conditions set as part the planning permission already granted

He said: “There can be no justification for the installation of a wood-burning stove for a shepherd who would no doubt be adequately dressed for the task, which itself would keep him or her warm.

“Heat is needed for lambs born in rain, which is the biggest factor in their survival.

“This is usually provided by infrared lamps, not a wood-burning stove.”

Longtown Group Parish Council representatives said their concerns included poor access to the shelter, no evidence of livestock on the farm and lack of clarification regarding the requirement of a wood burning stove for the open shelter.

They have requested a site meeting so that parish councillors can attend and gain clarity over the proposals.

Residents have until November 8 to comment on the plans which are expected to be determined by November 22.